Monday, September 3

Reiver Games - An Analysis

As many of you know, I ran a board games publishing company for five years: Reiver Games, from July 2006 to July 2011. I ended up selling off 3,000 games to a liquidator for 12p each, and lost about £8,750 (thankfully of insurance money and not my life savings!). Clearly something when very wrong.


And yet, I managed to sell 5,500 games and the company started off very successfully. So where did it all go so hideously wrong? What would I do differently if I was starting now with the knowledge I've gained the hard way?


After years trying to write tiny bits of computer games and a bad experience with Mighty Empires, I started designing Border Reivers at the end of 2002. I spent a couple of years playtesting it with a close group of not-really-gamer friends then I shelved it, and didn't come back to it until 2006 when I had the idea of forming Reiver Games and seeing if I had what it takes (and Border Reivers had what it takes) to sell a game.


I tried the game with real gamers in York and got pretty good feedback, so I convinced The Wife (using only fast talking and The Dummies Guide To Hypnotism) to let me invest £1,250 of our paltry savings in setting up a company to sell my game. I did all my sums and reckoned I could at a stretch sell 100 copies, and figured that £30 was a reasonable price for a home-made, limited edition game. One year after forming the company I has sold all my stock of Border Reivers, and my bank balance read £2,500 - a 100% ROI! So far, so awesome. During that year, I'd been extensively pimping my game on BGG and had been approached by another designer (actually several other designers, but only one that made the cut) and had decided that I should do a similar home-made, limited edition of his game: It's Alive! With the benefit of hindsight and a lot more gaming experience under my belt at the various cons and games clubs I'd attended, it was clear that Border Reivers wasn't actually a very good game. It's Alive! was a tighter game with much broader appeal (who doesn't love body parts?), so I took another punt and decided to hand-craft 300 copies of It's Alive!


By July 2008 I had sold all of those, and my bank balance read £4,500, nearly another 100% ROI. This was awesome! If I'd stopped there Reiver Games would have been fantastically successful - beyond my wildest dreams.


Then everything changed. During 2007 I'd been diagnosed with Multiple Sclerosis, and despite the treatment I was receiving I felt that my condition was worsening fairly quickly. I had a good job, but wasn't overly enamoured of it, and both The Wife and I were getting fed up with the amount of my 'free' time and holiday allowance I was spending on the company, cutting out and assembling games, checking and responding to emails, doing PR and blog posts and endless trips to Post Offices the UK over. This was not sustainable. Something had to give.


Conveniently, about this time, we checked my life insurance policy, and it turns out the critical illness cover I had taken out covered MS. A few phone calls and forms later, and I was in the frankly bizarre situation of being able to spend my own life insurance payout (without the fear of fraud charges that usually accompanies it!). We paid off the vast majority of our mortgage and (with more fast talking and liberal resorting to The Expert's Guide to Hypnotism) The Wife agreed to invest a chunk of the insurance money in Reiver Games (with another chunk put aside to live off while I had no salary income).


This was a turning point in lots of ways. It's when I started selling to shops, online stores and distributors, when I started getting the games made professionally, when I started attending Spiel in Essen and when the company started to fail.


I was keen that the company take off to the point where it could provide a salary for me and be a genuine job, not an excuse for bumming around. To do that I figured I would have to make and sell a lot of games. While the hand-made games had been a huge success for me, making them was a real chore. I wrecked our coffee table, was frequently cutting my hands and they often ached. Each copy of Border Reivers took 3 hours to assemble, It's Alive! one and a half - and that wasn't counting things and putting them in a box, it was cutting the box and tiles out of 2mm greyboard, folding, gluing, labelling, cutting the cards out and counting and sorting. I didn't fancy doing this day in, day out (plus I'd have ended up with RSI in no time!).


My first mistake was to price It's Alive! Second Edition at the same price as the hand-made edition, rather than the price dictated by the manufacturing cost. The second: getting a loan to publish Carpe Astra that I would spend the next two years paying £330 a month to service. This was compounded by manufacturing too many copies of those games. I made 3,000 It's Alive!, 2,000 Carpe Astra and 3,000 Sumeria. I should have done 2,000, 1,000 and 1,500 respectively - that's what I sold in a sensible time.


I tried to move from being a small hobby publisher with a dedicated, but small, army of fans to being a full-size pro publisher with professionally manufacturer games and sales and distribution channels. And I tried to do it too quickly. If I was a marketing genius, it's conceivable that it could be done, but it was a long shot and I didn't have it in me.


Of course, things have changed since then. KickStarter is a game-changer in the games publishing market, not only has it helped smaller companies like Tasty Minstrel flourish, but even big players like Eggertspiele and Steve Jackson Games have used it recently. It's a great combination of funds raising, market research, pre-order management and just listing a game there gets you loads of advertising to help you attract customers.


Although my first couple of years as a pro publisher were technically profitable, I was making very little money and it was clear that I had way too much inventory left. The loan payments were eroding the money I was getting back from sales and I didn't have enough cash to publish a new game - so, as with most businesses, it was cash-flow that killed me.


In hindsight, what I should have done was a halfway-house. Getting the games made professionally, but in small runs that I could sell directly to gamers and at cons. Going through shops and distributors, while it got me lots more sales, meant I had to make a lot of copies to get the costs low enough to sell to distributors and I had to squeeze my margins to unworkable levels. Maybe a thousand at a time would have been a sweet spot, but without shops and distributors on board even that may have been too many. And, had I waited a couple of years, I should have used KickStarter!

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thank you for publishing the great games Carpe Astra and Sumeria. Sorry that Reiver Games did not last.

Jack said...

Hiya,

I'm glad you enjoyed them :) I'm sorry Reiver Games didn't last too, but things are easier now with KickStarter, so all is not lost...

Cheers,

Jack

Anonymous said...

Really sorry to hear about this. Loved your edition of 'It's Alive'. Wanted to approach you with my own games for quite a long time (Card Games), but never had the nerve and ended up web publishing them and sodding the marketing.

Glad you tried for it, maybe one day the UK Kickstarter will get you back in the mix.

Jack said...

Hiya,

Yeah, It's Alive! was great fun :) I'm glad you got your games out there regardless web publishing is a lot less risky!

Cheers,

Jack

Steve said...

Thanks for the post! I have a question. You mention that you wouldn't have sold to game stores as soon as you did, but could you have given them a smaller inventory of your games or did they only want a certain minimum amount of your games before adding you to their shelves?

Jack said...

Hiya Steve,

The initial versions cost me 50% of retail to manufacture, which was pretty much what the shops wanted to pay me - i.e. I'd make no money on them. If I was to do another run I'd probably get it professionally manufactured, but a small run, so the costs would be similarly high and shops would be similarly unreachable.

Cheers,

Jack

Josiah White said...

Thanks for being open about this!

I've printed a few games myself and glued them to cereal box board but they don't look so nice. What was the quality of your first games? Did anyone complain?

Do you know if the liquidator made any money off your sold games?

Do you still have any copies left, for nostalgic purposes or for sale? Can I download a copy?

Are you thinking of getting back into it with Kickstarter, like a reprint of your favorite game?

Have you designed any games since then?

What is your favorite indie game right now? Big name game?

Jack said...

Hiya Josiah,

Sorry for the delay getting back to you, needed to find a chunk of time for writing the answers!

1) I think the quality was pretty good for what they were, obviously not as good as a game you'd buy in the shops, but not bad. You can see what they looked like if you read the history on this blog or search for Border Reivers and It's Alive! first edition on BoardGameGeek. I think my customers were happy with the quality - they knew they were getting hand-made games.

2) He sold them on immediately to a £1 shop chain in Scotland, so yes.

3) I have my demo copies left of each game, plus one new one in shrink of each game I got professionally manufactured. But they are still available from some shops and online stores. They weren't print and play, so not available for download.

4 & 5) I'm designing again (read the recent posts on this blog for more info on my current game Codename: Vacuum). If I get it finished then I can send it to another publisher or start up again as a self-publisher. If I do that I'll definitely use KickStarter.

6) The lines between Indie and professional companies are blurring with KickStarter allowing Indies to be pretty professional, but my favourite small publisher game is probably Braggart by Spiral Galaxy Games (which I nearly published myself) and from a large publisher right now is 7 Wonders.

Cheers,

Jack

David Dyer said...

Hi Jack,

Is there a way to get missing parts for Sumeria? One of my influence tokens has been lost. :( Thanks. David D.

Jack said...

Hiya David,

I'm sorry to say that I have neither any spare bits, nor any spare games to steal bits from any more. I sold the last lot off pretty cheap though, so you might find someone on BGG with a copy they'd part with at a minimal price. Sorry again :-(

Cheers,

Jack